Author: Margaret Wyman

ISBN: 1931857016

The following review was contributed by: Paul Lappen: CLICK TO VIEW Paul Lappen's Reviews 

This novel tells the story of the expedition of Lewis and Clark across early
1800s America, but not from the usual perspective. It doesn't use the point of
view of Lewis or Clark, but those of John Colter and George Shannon, two
Privates on the expedition.

Colter is an experienced mountain man and hunter, and Shannon is an
inexperienced graduate of West Point, who tries, unsuccessfully, to get promoted
to Lieutenant. The two Privates have an on and off relationship, ranging from
tolerating each other to, figuratively, wanting to kill each other. They also
have reasons for wanting to be away for a long time.

The expedition is one day after another of very hard work, rowing or pulling
their boat upriver, hauling supplies down the side of a waterfall, or walking
for days without seeing another person. Shannon's paralyzing fear of deep water
is no help. Colter seriously considers abandoning the expedition, and joining a
much more lucrative one, but his conscience gets in the way (he made an oath to
the expedition). Also holding him back is another member of the expedition,
Sergeant Ordway, who seems to have made it his personal mission to make Colter's
life a living hell.

Some of the Native American tribes encountered along the way, who Colter would
rather avoid at all costs, are decent and reasonable, while others are simply
bloodthirsty thieves. Among the former are the Mandans, near whom the expedition
makes camp for the winter. It seems to be almost a point of honor among the
Mandans for their women to be intimate with the "paleskins" (the men of the
expedition are happy to oblige). Against his better judgement, Colter meets, and
falls very hard for, a recently widowed woman named Fragrant Grass.

Every waking moment of Colter's life, after the expedition continues on its way,
is filled with thoughts of Fragrant Grass. Several chances to desert present
themselves, but Colter's conscience again gets in the way, along with Sergeant
Ordway. They reach the Pacific Coast, spend a miserable winter there, and Colter
gets back to Fragrant Grass, only to discover that she is no longer "available."

This is a fine piece of writing. The author does a good job with the characters,
and with showing a famous bit of American history from an uncommon perspective.
My only criticism about this book is that the length could have been reduced by
at least a few pages. I understand what the author was trying to do, and this is
the sort of story that takes a long time to tell, but, personally, this book did
not have to be 671 pages long. Don't let that get in the way of reading a really
interesting story.